Search

Saturday, 4 June 2011

US strike 'kills' key Pakistan militant Ilyas Kashmiri

File photo of Ilyas Kashmiri from 2001 Ilyas Kashmiri has long been considered a key militant figure in Pakistan
One of Pakistan's most senior militants has been killed in a US drone strike, locals and officials say.
Officials confirmed reports from locals that Ilyas Kashmiri had died in the overnight strike in the tribal region of South Waziristan.

Google to abandon older browsers


IE6 countdown campaign, BBC Microsoft has run an extended campaign to get people to abandon IE6 - one of its older browsers.Google is phasing out support for older browsers from 1 August.
Those using IE7, Safari 3, Firefox 3.5 and their predecessors to view Gmail, Google Calendar, Talk, Docs and Sites will then lose some functions.

Burkina Faso: Bloody end to Bobo Dioulasso mutiny

President Blaise Compaore. 1 April 2011 President Compaore sacked his security chiefs in April
At least seven people including a young girl have been killed in an exchange of fire as pro-government forces quelled a mutiny in Burkina Faso.The deaths came as elite forces engaged the rioting mutineers for the first time, encircling them at their military base in second city Bobo Dioulasso.

Tiananmen: Thousands in Hong Kong mark crackdown

Hong Kong vigil marking anniversary of Tiananmen massacre - 4 June 2011 Organisers said 150,000 people attended the vigil; police said 77,000 showed up
Tens of thousands of people have attended a candlelight vigil in Hong Kong to mark the 22nd anniversary of the Tiananmen crackdown in Beijing.
Hundreds of people were killed in the Chinese capital as soldiers and tanks moved to clear Tiananmen Square of pro-democracy demonstrators in 1989.

Chile: Puyehue volcano chain erupts, forcing evacuation

Thick plumes of smoke billow into the sky The Puyehue-Cordon-Caulle volcano range was last active in 1960          A chain of volcanoes has erupted in southern Chile, forcing the evacuation of thousands of residents.
Large columns of smoke have been rising from the Puyehue-Cordon-Caulle volcano range, about 800km (500 miles) south of the capital Santiago.

Peru: Fujimori and Humala face off in presidential vote

Peruvian presidential candidates, (from left) Ollanta Humala and Keiko Fujimori On the left and right of the political spectrum - presidential hopefuls Ollanta Humala and Keiko Fujimori
Voters in Peru are set to cast their ballots on Sunday in a closely fought presidential second-round run-off.They face a choice of Keiko Fujimori, daughter of jailed ex-president Alberto Fujimori, and Ollanta Humala, one-time ally of Venezuela's Hugo Chavez.

Libya: UK Apache helicopters used in Nato attacks

Apache AH Mk1

Apache AH Mk1
  • Crew: 2
  • Main weapon: 16 Hellfire anti-tank missiles
  • Length: 17.76m (58ft 3in)
  • Rotor span: 14.63m (48ft)
  • Cruising speed: 161mph (259km/h)
  • Range: 334 miles (537km)
  • Max mission duration: 2h 45min
Source: AgustaWestland

US employment growth registers sharp slowdown in May

Jobs fair in Los Angeles Despite the slowdown, it was the eighth consecutive month of positive jobs growth in the US
US employment growth slowed sharply in May, with only 54,000 net new jobs added during the month. Markets had expected a rise of 150,000. It follows a downwardly revised but still rapid 232,000 increase in April.

UN urges more funds for early HIV treatment

An Indian woman walks past a poster advertising an Aids-awareness programme in Bangalore (file) In India, the rate of new HIV infections fell by more than 50%, according to UNAids
The UN Programme on HIV/Aids (UNAids) has called for increased funding for the early treatment of people with HIV.
The head of the agency, Michael Sidibe, said a new study showed it could reduce the risk of HIV transmission by 96%.

Josephine Hart, author of Damage, dies in London

Josephine Hart Hart also founded West End Poetry Hour at the British Library
Irish-born author Josephine Hart, whose 1991 debut novel, Damage, was made into a film starring Jeremy Irons and Juliette Binoche, has died in London.

Lowry's Hawker's Cart sells for £555,000

LS Lowry's The Hawker's Cart The sale forms part of the academy's "rationalisation" programme
A Lowry painting, sold by The Royal Scottish Academy to raise money to buy new works, has fetched £555,000.

Glee star Jane Lynch to host Primetime Emmys

Glee's Jane Lynch Lynch won the outstanding supporting actress in a comedy series last year
Jane Lynch, the actress who picked up a Primetime Emmy playing cheer-leading coach Sue Sylvester in Glee last year - will host the 2011 awards.

Salmond appoints experts to look at Supreme Court

Supreme Court sign The UK's Supreme Court ruled on Nat Fraser's murder conviction
A group of experts has been established to look at the impact of the UK Supreme Court on Scotland's legal system.
First Minister Alex Salmond set up the review after raising his concerns about the role of the London-based court.

Moons like Earth's could be more common than we thought

Moon formation artwork
About one in 10 rocky planets around stars like our Sun may host a moon proportionally as large as Earth's, researchers say.
Our Moon is disproportionately large - more than a quarter of Earth's diameter - a situation once thought to be rare.

Pakistan largest CNG user


Pakistani commuters travel in a compressed natural gas (CNG) powered Green Bus on the city's busiest street in Lahore on May 10, 2010. – AFP Photo

Resurgence of the veil

DURING the first half of the 20th century, millions of Muslim women decided to abandon the head coverings their mothers had used; in the second half of the century, millions of Muslim women resumed wearing the veil.

View from US: WikiLeaks: wackiest whistleblower

Initiated readers often bemoan the lack of investigative journalism in Pakistan. The TV talk shows are horse and pony shows, they contend. The newspapers are either too sensational or too timid, they say. Nobody has the inside on what’s going on behind the Foreign Office or the GHQ; the Presidency, the PM House or the American Embassy, they argue.

No safe bed at night

I NEVER met Syed Saleem Shahzad. But like all journalists in Pakistan and elsewhere in this globalised, interconnected world, I am saddened, alarmed and angry at his killing.

The internal challenge

HAS the time come for the Congress high command to issue notices to Prime Minister Manmohan Singh, his virtual deputy Pranab Mukherjee and his principal interlocutor for officially unofficial dialogue Kapil Sibal, for gross violation of discipline?

The debate on provinces

ASSERTIONS to the contrary notwithstanding, governance in Pakistan remains attuned to
political symbolism and personal ambitions. The movement for the creation of more provinces is a manifestation of both.

‘Gunsmoke’ actor James Arness dies at 88


One of US television's most enduring stars during the show's 20-year run from 1955-75, he returned in a number of “Gunsmoke” TV movies in the 1980s and early 1990s. - AP (File Photo)

Malaysian to tweet apology 100 times in defamation deal


The blogger was unable to finance apology advertisements, so the Twitter apology was decided as a compromise. The sentence has caused a buzz on the internet: "Twitter defamer ordered to apologize Bart Simpson style" reported Michael Trei of Dvice.com. - File Photo by AP/The Simpsons

British singer Adele cancels US tour to heal throat


She had already postponed five shows under doctor's orders, but while resting in Los Angeles she saw a specialist “who determined it was imperative that she take the next few weeks to recover with absolute voice rest.” - AFP (File Photo)

A feast for the senses on the Venice lagoon


Visitors look at an installation by artist Tabaimo at the Japan pavillion of the 54th International Art Exhibition of the Venice Biennale contemporary arts festival, in Venice. The festival opens on Saturday June 4th and runs until November 27. - AP Photo

Nadal and Federer excel to seal dream final


Federer returns the ball to Djokovic. – AP Photo

History-maker Li wins French Open for China


Li Na of China raises the trophy after winning her women's final against Francesca Schiavone of Italy at the French Open tennis tournament at the Roland Garros stadium in Paris June 4, 2011. -Reuters Photo

New York Times names first woman executive editor


New York Times managing editor Jill Abramson poses in this undated handout photo. NYT named Abramson as its first woman executive editor, putting her in control of one the world's most respected newspapers as the industry struggles to keep advertisers and readers. – REUTERS Photo

Saudi plans to build 16 nuclear reactors by 2030


A file picture shows the nuclear power plant in the Swiss town of Leibstadt some 50 km (31 miles) northwest of Zurich The Saudi Arabia is planning to construct 16 nuclear plants in next 20 years. – Reuters Photo

Mosquitoes are suckered in new malaria research


The findings have been tested in a small-scale experiment in Kenya, using huts where alluring plumes of CO2 were released to attract mosquitoes and odour molecules were released to bamboozle them. – AFP Photo

WHO: E. coli outbreak caused by new strain


Hilde Kruse, a food safety expert at the WHO, told The Associated Press that ‘‘this is a unique strain that has never been isolated from patients before.” – AP Photo

Germany, Italy surge on as France are frustrated


Italy's Giampaolo Pazzini (2nd R) celebrates with teammates after scoring against Estonia. -Reuters Photo


Verdict on Afridi’s case in 30 days: Tafazzul


Both PCB and Afridi have the option of approaching an independent appellate tribunal if they are not happy with the order of the disciplinary committee. -AP Photo-AFP Photo

Ex-Secretary of State Lawrence Eagleburger dies


Lawrence Eagleburger, head of the International Commission of Holocaust Era Claims and former US secretary of state, speaks about the World War II slaughter of six million Jews at the end of a visit by the commission to the Yad Vashem Holocaust Memorial in this June 23, 1999 file photo. Eagleburger died on June 4, 2011 at the age of 80 years old according to local media. -Reuters Photo

Blast at Kandahar university kills two


An AFP reporter at the scene said he heard a second blast after police cordoned off the area. — Photo by AP

Nato: 2 troops killed in southern Afghanistan


The US-led coalition said both service members were killed in separate insurgent attacks Friday in the south. - AP (File Photo)

Bahrain GP reinstated, India to end season

bahrain gp, bahrain grand prix, formula one, f1, formula one 2011
Bahrain had opted to call off the race earlier due to unrest in the country. -Reuters Photo

India launch Caribbean tour with T20 win

Palestinians agree to attend Mideast conferenceIsraeli soldiers patrol the border between Syria and Israel, close to the northern Druze village of Majdal Shams, in the Golan Heights. -Reuters Photo


Israeli soldiers patrol the border between Syria and Israel, close to the northern Druze village of Majdal Shams, in the Golan Heights. -Reuters Photo
RAMALLAH: The Palestinians on Saturday accepted a French invitation to attend a conference in Paris aimed at reviving peace talks with Israel, as their strategy to bypass negotiations and seek U.N. recognition of a Palestinian state appeared to be unraveling.
Nabil Abu Rdeneh, an adviser to Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas, said the Palestinians were prepared to go to Paris and were waiting for Israeli and American responses.
French Foreign Minister Alain Juppe extended the invitation earlier this week in a visit to the region, saying the conference could take place later this month. Israel has not replied to Juppe’s invitation and had no comment Saturday on the Palestinian acceptance, which came with no conditions attached.
The Palestinians have refused to return to the bargaining table for months because Israel has rejected their demand to halt all settlement construction on lands they claim for a future state. At the same time, they have been preparing to ask the U.N. General Assembly in September to recognize a Palestinian state, with or without a peace deal.
Palestinian officials said they had no high hopes for a French-led conference but would attend in an effort to restart talks that broke down in late 2008 and revived only briefly this past September before collapsing over Israeli settlement construction.
Historically, the U.S., not Europe, has taken the lead in trying to wrest an agreement from Israel and the Palestinians, and the Obama administration has been cool to the French proposal.
U.S. officials say they have privately discouraged it, but the administration has not taken a public position on the conference. State Department spokesman Mark Toner noted on Friday that Juppe would meet with Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton on Monday in Washington.
”The secretary looks forward to meeting with him and they’ll discuss ways forward,” Toner said.
Two weeks ago, President Barack Obama tried to entice the Palestinians to resume talks by asserting in a high-profile policy speech that Israel’s boundaries before the 1967 Mideast war should be a starting point for talks on future borders, with mutually agreed land swaps that would let Israel hold on to major West Bank settlement blocs.
The Palestinians had long sought an explicit statement to this effect from Washington. But they were disappointed by the peace blueprint Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu outlined later in a speech before the U.S. Congress, dismissing it as a non-starter because it disregards many of their key demands.

Yemeni president arrives in Saudi, not quitting: official


Anti-government protestors react during a demonstration demanding the resignation of Yemeni President Ali Abdullah Saleh, as they hold a defaced poster of Saleh, in Sanaa, Yemen, Saturday, June 4, 2011. Five top members of the government were sent to Saudi Arabia for treatment of wounds they suffered in a rebel rocket attack on the presidential palace, the official government news agency reported Saturday. President Ali Abdullah Saleh was slightly injured. A adefaced poster showing Yemeni President Ali Abdullah Saleh, is held center by a protestor. — AP Photo
RIYADH: Yemen’s beleaguered President Ali Abdullah Saleh, wounded in shelling of his compound in the capital Sanaa, arrived late Saturday in Riyadh for treatment but has not stood down, a Saudi official said.
“President Saleh has arrived in Riyadh for treatment, but he will return to Yemen,” the official told AFP on condition of anonymity.
In Sanaa, a presidential palace source confirmed his departure but refused to say any more.
Under Yemen’s constitution, Saleh will be replaced during his absence by Deputy President Abdel Rabbo Mansur Hadi.
Saleh has refused to give up the power he has held for nearly 33 years despite four months of angry and violent protests against his rule.
He notably refused to sign a plan worked out by the Gulf Arab monarchies, headed by Saudi Arabia, for a peaceful transfer of power.
Saleh, 69, arrived aboard a Saudi medical aircraft while a second plane carried members of his family, the Saudi official said.
His eldest son Ahmad, commander of the elite Republican Guard, remained in Yemen. The opposition says Ahmad was preparing to take over from his father before the popular uprising started.
Saleh was immediately taken to the Saudi capital’s military hospital, the official said.
Saleh was wounded on Friday when a shell hit the presidential palace’s mosque during prayers, killing 11 and wounding 124 people, according to a government official.
In an audio statement broadcast on state television late Friday as he was being treated at the defence ministry hospital in Sanaa, Saleh said he was “well, in good health.”The embattled leader suffered “burns and scratches to the face and chest,”an official said after the ruling General People’s Congress said he was “lightly wounded in the back of the head.”His regime has blamed the attack on powerful dissident tribal leader Sheikh Sadiq al-Ahmar, whose fighters have been battling government forces in the Yemeni capital since a truce crumbled on Tuesday.
Prime Minister Ali Mohammed Mujawar and four other senior Yemeni officials wounded in the shelling of the presidential compound were also transferred to Saudi Arabia for treatment, Yemen’s state news agency Saba reported.
A precarious calm meanwhile returned to Yemen’s capital on Saturday as Saleh vowed to hit back after the mosque attack and a top general defected to the opposition.
Sporadic shelling and rocket fire rattled Al-Hassaba district of northern Sanaa where Ahmar has his base, witnesses said.
The clashes left one person killed and dozens wounded, a medical official said before the fighting subsided later.
A source close to Sheikh Sadiq said the powerful tribal chief was “committed to a ceasefire based on mediation efforts led by Saudi King Abdullah and Crown Prince Sultan bin Abdul Aziz despite the continuous shelling” by Saleh forces.
Saleh, in power in Sanaa since 1978, hit out in his broadcast at “the sons of Al-Ahmar” – Sheikh Sadiq and his brothers – and urged “the security forces to purge state institutions of these gangs.”Washington condemned the violence, including the palace attack, and called for Saleh to transfer power.
Russia expressed its concern at the “terrible civil war” in Yemen and urged the leadership to accept a Gulf Cooperation Council-sponsored plan for him to step down in return for immunity.
The parliamentary opposition on Saturday called for an “immediate”ceasefire and condemned “the dangerous twist which the clashes have taken in targeting the homes of citizens, the presidential palace, and vital installations.”After Saleh last month refused to sign the GCC deal, opposition tribesmen seized public buildings in Sanaa, sparking clashes with Saleh forces.
Amid the latest escalation, the European Union activated a mechanism to evacuate its citizens, and Germany ordered the closure of its embassy.
After Friday’s presidential compound attack, Yemeni troops shelled the home of Sheikh Hamid, a brother of Sheikh Sadiq, in apparent retaliation.
Shelling in Hada neighbourhood also targeted the homes of two other Ahmar brothers, Hemyar and Mizhij, and that of dissident General Ali Mohsen al-Ahmar.
The attack on Sheikh Hamid’s home killed 10 people and wounded 35, his office said.
More than 70 people have now been confirmed killed in the fighting in Sanaa since a fragile four-day truce collapsed between Ahmar tribesmen and Saleh loyalists.
In the flashpoint city of Taez, the commander of the 33rd armoured division, General Yahya al-Hashidi, joined protesters calling for Saleh to quit, a military official told AFP.
Hashidi’s division controls Yemen’s southwest which includes the Bab al-Mandab Strait, the strategic entrance to the Indian Ocean from the Red Sea.
Nationwide, more than 200 demonstrators have been killed since the anti-Saleh protests erupted, according to an AFP tally based on reports from medics and rights activists.

PPP raring to have a go at PML-N in Punjab


Babar Awan has been asked by the PPP leadership to devise a strategy for next week’s session of the Punjab Assembly, said sources.—APP photo
ISLAMABAD: A group within the Pakistan People’s Party believes the party should pay the Pakistan Muslim League-N in the same coin in the Punjab Assembly for its budget day spectacle in the National Assembly.
According to sources, former law minister Babar Awan has been asked by the party leadership to devise a strategy for next week’s session of the Punjab Assembly, when the PML-led provincial government will present the budget.
Mr Awan is expected to chair a meeting of the PPP parliamentary group in the provincial assembly on Monday.
Speaking at a news conference here on Saturday, Mr Awan assailed the PML-N for its members’ noisy protest in the National
Assembly during Friday’s budget speech, accusing them of taking the country’s politics back to the 1990s.
He said the PML-N knew that the PPP would become the largest party in the upper house of parliament after next year’s Senate elections.
He said the PML-N should wait till the general elections in 2013, but “these people are wrongly dreaming for mid-term polls”.
“We will hold by-elections wherever any seat will fall vacant,” he said in an apparent reference to reports that the PML-N might consider resigning from the National Assembly to force mid-term elections.
The PPP leader said the country could not afford a ‘Bangladesh model’ or dictatorship and the people did not consider the
PML-N a genuine opposition.
He said Punjab was under heavy debt because of bad governance. He dubbed the Ashiana housing scheme for low-income groups announced by Punjab Chief Minister Shahbaz Sharif as an ‘afsana’ or fraud.
Mr Awan said the PML-N was criticising the government for its pro-US stance, but it was under that party’s government that the US had violated the country’s sovereignty for the first time when Aimal Kansi, a Pakistani wanted for a deadly shooting at the CIA headquarters, had been handed over to America.
Criticising the opposition for rejecting a commission formed by the government to investigate the killing of Osama bin Laden in Abbottabad, Mr Awan said the PML-N should tell the nation how many commissions it had set up on major incidents like the Aimal Kansi case and the Kargil operation during its own rule in the 1990s.
He criticised the Punjab government for not having appointed a finance minister after forcing out the PPP from the provincial coalition early this year.
PML-N spokesman Ahsan Iqbal said his party was ready to face any eventuality in Punjab Assembly as it had already faced what he called “the worst and undemocratic protest” by the PPP and the PML-Q which had obstructed the house’s proceedings for a week by creating rumpus.
“We will see the democratic attitude of those in Punjab Assembly who are today accusing us of adopting a non-democratic
attitude during the National Assembly’s budget session.”
Responding to Mr Awan’s allegation of not having set up a commission on the Kargil operation, he said the PML-N government had even sacked the then army chief, Gen Pervez Musharraf, before being toppled through a coup.
The Leader of Opposition in Punjab Assembly, Raja Riaz of the PPP, said the opposition had the right to protest in the provincial assembly over wrong policies of the government.
However, the opposition would play a positive role in the provincial assembly in line with the late Benazir Bhutto’s policy of reconciliation, he said.
He the disruption of the assembly proceedings by the PPP and the PML-Q in the past was a reaction to PML-N’s ‘unconstitutional and illegal’ step of accepting turncoats into its fold.
He said the PPP parliamentary group would devise its strategy for the budget session on Monday.
Meanwhile, Prime Minister Yousuf Raza Gilani also said in Multan that the PPP would uphold democratic norms during the presentation of Punjab’s budget.

CJ calls for change in law to stop Vani


Chief Justice, Justice Iftikhar Mohammad Chaudhary chairs a meeting of Law and Justice Commission at Supreme Court building in Islamabad.-APP
ISLAMABAD: The Law and Justice Commission will suggest amendments in the law to check the practice of offering girls and women in marriage to settle feuds between two tribes on the intervention of jirgas and panchayats.
A meeting of the commission, chaired by Chief Justice Iftikhar Mohammad Chaudhry at the Supreme Court building here on Saturday, took a serious note of the practice of Badal-i-Sulha (compensation for compromise) in rural areas.
The chief justice said there was a need for fresh legislation on issues related to public importance and bringing the existing ones into accord with the changing needs of society.
He stressed the need for simplification of laws for easy comprehension and removing inconsistencies. Justice Iftikhar urged that legislation should be made after due process as provided in the Constitution.
He said: “The system of administration of justice revolves around the provisions of Constitution which provides safeguards for fundamental rights of the citizens; therefore, it is incumbent upon all the institutions to adhere to the provisions of Constitution in discharging their functions.”
Although Pakistan ratified UN Convention on the Rights of Child in 1990 that prohibits child marriages, it seldom honours the commitment and girls are commonly offered into marriage either in exchange for money because of extreme poverty or for settling disputes with the exchange of girls known as vani or swara and the use of girls as compensation for crimes.
The official announcement issued by the commission did not specify the provisions of law proposed to be amended, but legal experts were of the view that it was talking about the Child Marriage Restraint Act, 1929, which suggests simple punishment of one month or more with a very meagre amount of fine, and some amendments in the Pakistan Penal Code.
The amendments to be suggested would focus more on introducing stringent punitive actions against those involved in the heinous crime against women.
Advocate Naseer Ahmed Chaudhry when asked to comment was not approved of bringing any amendment in the law and said it was the failure of the authorities concerned to take notice of infraction in laws because of their laidback attitude in strict implementation of regulations.
The commission also examined proposals for the repeal of Federal Court Act, 1937, and recommended that the enactment being redundant should be repealed.
The Government of India Act, 1935, had envisaged for the first time the concept of the federal court that had the jurisdictions to decide matters in dispute between the central government and the states (provinces) then. Thus the federal court was constituted in 1937 with Sir Mauris Gwyer being the first chief justice of the federal court of India.
After the creation of Pakistan, a similar federal court was constituted and the jurisdiction exercised by the Privy Council in relation to appeals coming from the high courts was conferred to the federal court by enacting the Privy Council (Abolition of Jurisdiction) Act, 1950, by the constituent assembly of Pakistan.
The federal court continued to function till 1956 when the first constitution of Pakistan was adopted and the Supreme Court of Pakistan (SCP) was created while the jurisdiction exercised by the federal court was conferred on the SCP. Thus the federal court act becomes a dead letter.

Bomb attack kills six near Peshawar


“The blast took place at a bus stop and it seems the bomb was planted,” said Raheem Khan, a police inspector. — File Photo
PESHAWAR: A bomb attack near the Pakistani city of Peshawar killed at least six people on Sunday, police said.
“The blast took place at a bus stop and it seems the bomb was planted,” said Raheem Khan, a police inspector. Ten people were wounded.
Pakistan’s Taliban militants, who have close ties to al Qaeda, have carried out a series of attacks to avenge the killing of Osama bin Laden by U.S. special forces in a Pakistani town on May 2.
They have attacked paramilitary cadets, a US consulate convoy, a naval base and other targets.
The United States reiterated its call on Pakistan to become a more reliable partner in its war on militancy after it was discovered that bin Laden had apparently been living in Pakistan for years.
The Taliban have proven resilient in the face of several army offensives against their strongholds, seemingly carrying out suicide bombings at will.

Five-year tax holiday offered on loan-free investments


ISLAMABAD: The finance minister announced on Saturday a five-year tax holiday on loan-free equity investments, called for checks and oversight of defence expenditures and identified the rising debt servicing as a major challenge for the country.
Speaking at a post-budget press conference, Dr Abdul Hafeez Shaikh said the government had prepared the budget with an eye on the general election.
There was a crisis-like situation on the one hand where the government had to create a balance between income and expenditures and, on the other, people expected relief and job creation.
“We have not been much successful in creating jobs and achieving higher growth,” the minister concededBut, Dr Shaikh, an effort had been made in the budget to provide incentives for investment. He said there had been a demand to facilitate investors who wanted to set up new factories and businesses.
“Therefore, it has been decided that there will be no tax at all for five years for those who invest their own money without raising loans.”
An official said that given the crowding out of private sector because of heavy government borrowings, the government wanted to induce capital from outside the banking system to trigger investment and, at the same time, attract black money into the formal economy.
Dr Shaikh said the government had given incentives to companies to get them enlisted on stock exchanges. The government would reduce tax rates and number of taxes to ease burden on the existing taxpayers.
He said the government had promised last year to reduce the rate of general sales tax its reforms process completed and powerful people were brought to the GST net.
“We have made substantial progress in expanding the GST net by withdrawing exemptions on fertilisers, pesticides, tractors, leather, surgical items, sports goods, carpets and some other sectors through logic and discussions. We want this time to establish credibility that promises are honoured and hence one per cent reduction in GST —from 17 to 16 per cent. This will cause a loss of Rs36 billion to the government,” he said.
Dr Hafeez said defence and debt serving costs were unavoidable. The government, he added, was trying to reduce expenditures but some of them were out of its control.
He said that security and defence were national imperatives and the government and the nation would have to sacrifice for the defence of the country. But, he added, time had come that like developed countries the use of defence allocation was improved with a better check and balance.
The minister said it had been Pakistan’s historic failure that successive governments had not been able to tax well-off people and relying on external and international borrowings to meet expenditure, which affected the social sector and infrastructure development.
Dr Hafeez said the 18th Amendment and 7th National Finance Commission Award gave greater empowerment to the provinces through additional resources and responsibilities.
He said it was good to give more autonomy to the provinces, but Rs350 billion additional transfers, as a result, affected federal finances.
He explained that the reduction in subsidies would not result in inflation because the subsidies would be made more targeted so that these were not misused by wealthy people. He said debts should now be avoided to take the country to the path of self-reliance.
In reply to a question about tax on agricultural income, Mr Shaikh said people should respect the Constitution or change it because it was a provincial subject. He said the tax was already there but its collection had been declining because nobody ever issued notices for its recovery or filing of returns.
He said that agricultural income tax collection in Sindh stood at Rs500 million in 2000 but dropped to Rs150 million last year.
He did not respond when asked how the federal government could introduce GST on services when it was also a provincial subject and was trying to pass on the responsibility of tax on agricultural income to the provinces.
Secretary Finance Waqar Masud Khan said some comments that tax targets for the next year were not realistic did not take into account 16 per cent normal growth in taxes over the current year’s expected collection of Rs1580 billion and additional earnings of about Rs119 billion through expansion of GST and better collection through administrative measures.

“It’s a pro-poor budget!”


A poverty-stricken Pakistani family gets food at a charity outlet in Karachi, Pakistan on Friday, June 3, 2011. Pakistan said Friday it was aiming to broaden its tax base in the next fiscal year, part of budget measures to fund a budget deficit and revive an economy battered by years of mismanagement, floods and surging violence by Islamist militants. – AP Photo
ISLAMABAD: Parliamentarians on Saturday hailed the budget for fiscal year 2011-12 and termed it as an effort to give relief to the poor.
Talking to APP, the politicians said that the budget aimed at redressing the poverty issue in Pakistan and provide relief to the masses.
“The budget would provide relief to the masses at a time when the country was faced with crises. This is the fourth consecutive budget presented during the democratic era with a special focus on providing relief to the poor masses while keeping in view the ground realities. It has come up to the expectations of masses,” said Chairperson of National Assembly Standing Committee on Social Welfare and Special Education, Rubina Saadat Qaim Khani.
She strongly criticised the members who created a rumpus in the assembly during the session yesterday and went on to allege, “Those who were shouting are in fact tax defaulters and want to destabilise the country.
Sharing a similar opinion, Chairperson of Benazir Income Support Programme (BISP) Farzana Raja said, “The negative propaganda of opposition is an attempt to destabilise democracy in the country.”
“The idea, as proposed in the budget, for generating revenue through raising tax base is a good step. It will be a great success if the government manages to achieve the targets as laid down in the budget. This step would help reduce dependence on foreign aid and make the country self reliant.”
Minister of State for Foreign Affairs, Hina Rabbani Khar said that an additional amount of Rs 600 billion for the provinces in the budget envisions a ‘prosperous Pakistan’.
She said the government has spent funds in three major areas including energy, flood hit areas and law enforcement agencies. “We have spent an amount of Rs 80 billion in energy sector last year which has now been raised up to Rs 280 billion so that the common man could be provided electricity,” she added.
Parliamentary Secretary for Health, Mehreen Razzaq Bhutto praised the budget and said, “The increase in the salaries of government employees by up to 15 percent will help improve their living standard.”
Sharing her thoughts on the budget, she said, “Less than five million people pay the tax and this has been a factor in compelling many people to live below poverty line. Long term planning has been announced in this budget to bring more people in the tax net.”
Commenting on the budget, PPP leader and former Minister of State for Interior, Tasneem Ahmed Qureshi said that the 15 percent increase in salaries of government servants, 20 percent in pension of retired servants and elimination of central excise and regulatory duty on different items were “good news for the general public”.
In a similar vain, PPP Senator Islamuddin Shaikh termed the budget 2011- 12 as “people friendly”.
“Billions of rupees have been allocated for the energy sector which shows the concerns of the PPP about the needs of the masses. The budget would help overcome poverty, backwardness and would provide better relief to common man,” he said.
Talking about the General Sales Tax (GST), he said, “The government has reduced the rate of the GST from 17 percent to 16 percent which would benefit the poor masses.”
While terming the budget “pro-masses”, MNA Afzal Nadeem Chan and PPP district president, Hamid Nawaz Awan termed the PML-N leaders’ behaviour of throwing bangles during the budget speech as “uncivilised and childish”.
“Why did they not throw bangles at Nawaz Sharif when he left Pakistan after begging pardon from a dictator who had toppled his government?” they questioned.

Comment: The 2011-2012 budget session


Federal Minister for Finance, Dr Abdul Hafeez Sheikh delivering budget speech 2011-12 in National Assembly. -APP Photo
The antics at the National Assembly on Friday evening were reminiscent of the scene at a wedding. Two sides out to outshine each other. The competition is serious but both sides know the rules of the game — no one leaves the dance floor or ruins the other’s performance by switching off the music or tripping those swinging to the beat.
There is but one rule — and that is to let both the adversaries carry on till the end.
This is exactly what the budget session on Friday evening threw up. The Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) was in no mood to stage a walkout and let the government present the budget with quiet dignity. And Finance Minister Hafeez Shaikh droned on with the facts, figures and statistics amid the din, with little care that he communicated nothing — clearly he was much inspired by his former president, General (retd) Pervez Musharraf.
To prove that they were more serious than ever before, the PML-N members no longer stood in their seats and shouted slogans as they did during Pervez Musharraf’s speeches. They upped the ante by gathering in front of Sheikh’s desk and out-shouted him throughout.
The khaata peeta PML-N women led the assault; they formed the first rotund line of attack. The men all gathered behind as Nisar Ali Khan and Javed Hashmi stood nearby, looking on approvingly as the besotted and proud parents of the young ones who are dancing their hearts out.
What exactly they were protesting remained unclear but then when has politics ever been about issues in Pakistan?
As a result their slogans varied from rejecting the Americans to the International Monetary Fund to “Zardari rule” to a few Leftist favourites thrown in here and there.
To fend off possible attacks from the women cavalry, the Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) could only send in reinforcements in the shape of Information Minister Firdous Ashiq Awan, who sat alert next to Shaikh (the rest of the PPP women are just not militant or healthy enough).
Khursheed Shah also hovered around — effectively he flapped away Ahsan Iqbal’s inexplicable and ineffective stunt to present aroti to the finance minister. (For the rest of the session, the PML-N spokesman just walked in and out from one door or the other.)
A word of advice Mr Iqbal, a momentary jiggle or ungainly move just does not cut it.
But if there was one man who forced one’s sympathy in all of this, it was columnist-turned-politician Ayaz Amir. He stood there — at a little distance, the intellectual and scholarly uncle who had to participate in the family wedding but just could not bring himself to condone the silly dancing, leave alone join it.
Honestly speaking, he would have blended right in with the PPP wallahs lounging in their seats or socialising with each other. They did support their side alright — at cue they banged their desks in unison to let the audience know that the finance minister had spoken of some achievement of their government. Their complacency was akin to the groom’s side: comfortable in the knowledge that the budget will eventually pass and that it was wise to save their energies for the serious battles to come as they do after the ceremonies are over.
And in all of this, where were the other opposition and treasury parties — Jamiatul Ulema-e-Islam–Fazl, the Muttahida Qaumi Movement and the Pakistan Muslim League–Quaid?
All of them were clearly waiting for the dinner to be served and the party to end.

Health sector ‘criminally ignored’


LAHORE: Shocked by the meager budgetary allocation of Rs40 billion both for health and education sectors in the fiscal year 2011-12, medical associations and experts termed it a ‘major blunder’ on the part of the federal government.
They said the government did not even touch the pro-poor vital running health schemes like hepatitis control programme, polio eradication, HIV/AIDs, tuberculosis, malaria, dengue eradication and other infectious diseases’ programmes besides the primary healthcare, maternal and child healthcare programme showing the apathy of the government.
Most of country’s population belonging to lower and middle classes was suffering from several infectious diseases.
Medical experts believed that the budgetary allocation for health announced by the federal finance minister was nearly 15 per cent less than that of the last year.
Medical Teachers Association’s Punjab president Prof Dr Javed Akram outrightly rejected the health budgetary proposal saying this was the biggest joke the federal government had played in ‘untimely session’ to the poor of the country.
He said the motherland had continuously been challenged by epidemics and communicable and non-communicable diseases.
“The prevalence of hypertension in Pakistan has risen to 50 per cent while the health sector is struggling with the epidemic of dengue, hepatitis and several other communicable diseases.”
He said “the budgetary proposal of Rs40 billion for the year 2011-12 for health and education sectors is mere a peanut.”
“Health and education sectors are meant to provide relief to the common man and it seems that legislators are not interested
in the welfare of health and education of the poor”, he said.
Dr Akram demanded a minimum of two per cent of the GDP to be spent on the health sector which was the only way to provide relief to the deprived people of the country.
He expressed his utter disappointment that not a single penny had been allocated in the current proposal for the prevention of diseases.
Regarding the taxation on milk powder meant for infants, he said this mode of infant feeding was generally used by the poor to provide nourishment to the growing child at an affordable price in a hygienic way.
Dr Akram warned that the MTA Punjab would lead a long march of all healthcare providers to the Parliament House if the budget allocation for health was not reviewed.
Pakistan Medical Association’s Punjab chapter president Prof Dr Ashraf Nizami said the proposed budget allocation for health showed that the health sector was not the priority of the government.
He also expressed his disquiet for ignoring necessary and life-saving health schemes in budgetary allocations saying that the TB was 5.1 per cent of the total diseases burden in the country.
“Pakistan ranks at eight in 22 “high burden” countries of TB and at the top on the polio list in the region”, he said.
He, however, hailed the decision of decreasing excise duty on some antibiotic medicines to make them affordable for poor patients.
Dr Shahid Malik, an expert on health issues, said if budgetary allocations for the health sector were calculated, the per head contribution would not be more than 25 paisa.
He said there was still confusion about the eight running health programmes, including polio eradication scheme, as nobody knew who would run or finance these initiatives because the federal government had not allocated any amount in this regard.

The imperatives of economic self-reliance


It is depressing to recall that despite the short-lived spurt in 2004-2007 (seven per cent) the average growth rate has declined from six per cent in 1985-95 to 4.4 per cent in the 15-year period from 1996–2001 and only 2.9 per cent in 2007-2011. – File Photo
THE difficult economic outlook on the eve of the budget is not very reassuring. The lethal combination of low growth and high inflation is accompanied by a high fiscal deficit, growing unemployment and a rising debt burden.
Similarly, the sense of despondency and despair arising from rising insurgency and a difficult security situation on our eastern and western borders, has been compounded by the Abbottabad operation of May 2, creating new strains in Pakistan`s relation with the US and seriously eroding the image of the army.
Against this background, there is widespread consensus across the political spectrum that the country cannot safeguard its sovereignty and vital national interests unless it reduces dependence on foreign loans and grants, especially those that come with political- and security-related conditionalities.
The first milestone on the road to self-reliance is a decisive revival of the economy to accelerate the growth rate to five-six per cent in 2011-15 and beyond. It is depressing to recall that despite the short-lived spurt in 2004-2007 (seven per cent) the average growth rate has declined from six per cent in 1985-95 to 4.4 per cent in the 15-year period from 1996–2001 and only 2.9 per cent in 2007-2011.
The factors that have contributed to this slowdown are varied and complex, but the forthcoming budget must prioritise revival of growth in the following sub-sectors.
One, accelerated growth in small-scale industrial and commercial sectors. Pakistan has 3.3 million economic establishments of which 90 per cent employ less than five workers and another four per cent between 6-50 workers. An active policy of support and facilitation to this sub-sector through organisations like Small and Medium Enterprise Development Authority (Smeda) and Technical Education and Vocational Training Authority (Tevta) can stimulate investment, growth and much needed employment. The provincial governments can play a predominant role in promoting entrepreneurship by supporting larger firms in providing marketing channels and technical assistance to smaller firms.
Two, a bold programme of incentives and policies for an export-led growth strategy. This will include higher priority for value addition in textile and other sectors, strong partnership with exporters` associations to find new markets for value-added products and special fiscal and credit support.
Three, attracting foreign investment from the Middle East in agriculture and livestock sectors. Many of these countries need an assured supply of items like wheat, rice, milk, poultry meat, edible oil, flowers, fruit and vegetables and are ready to invest on the basis of longer-term supply contracts.
While the policy of leasing land to foreign investors has many adverse implications, the federal and provincial governments can facilitate longer-term supply contracts between large importing companies in the Middle East and corporate entities in Pakistan which have benefited from the recent spurt in commodity prices. Such arrangements, which have to be guaranteed by the government against unexpected policy changes, will also accelerate the process of diversification into high value agriculture and generate additional employment.
Importantly, these measures to stimulate growth will not yield full potential unless the structural weaknesses responsible for the decline in the investment-to-GDP ratio from over 20 per cent in the early 1990s to less than 16 per cent in the past three years are addressed. This decline is partly due to the deteriorating security situation but also due to the shortage and high cost of energy, growing incidence of corruption and the rising cost of doing business in Pakistan. These negative factors must be addressed on a war footing to improve investment climate in the country.
The third set of policies required to achieve economic self-reliance lie in the traditional area of fiscal deficit, inflation and monetary policy but through non-traditional policies. Measures to increase the tax-to-GDP ratio and to reduce non-development expenditures, no doubt, deserve high priority to narrow the gap between revenue and expenditure, but there is also a dire need to seek a judicious balance between growth and macro-economic stability.If we continue current efforts to control inflation through tighter demand management and higher interest rates, we might reach what the late Dr Mahbubul Haq called “the equilibrium of the graveyard”. It should be possible to devise a discriminatory credit policy that promotes industrial growth, exports and employment generation along with an energy policy that provides and assures electricity and gas to these sectors at affordable prices. Unless we take such steps to reduce the cost of doing business in Pakistan, our growth will remain low and the problem of poverty and unemployment will become even more explosive.
Finally, economic self-reliance has become a political imperative which, if properly pursued, can overcome the sense of political and social anxiety which has descended on this nation like a dark cloud. What is needed is a message of hope that will rekindle the confidence and trust of the people and the interest and enthusiasm of local and foreign investors.
The writer is a former finance minister

FBR target pegged on indirect taxes


People listening to the budget speech in Islamabad.—Online
ISLAMABAD: Sparing the affluent class any new income tax, the government has continued with its earlier strategy of indirect taxation by focusing on the general sales tax and the federal excise duty to raise more than Rs140 billion.
The budget proposes to collect Rs31.3 billion from new general sales tax (GST) and Federal Excise Duty (FED) taxes.
Of these Rs10 billion will be raised from imposing sales tax on army owned general stores, Rs9 billion from the revised duty on cigarettes, Rs7 billion from GST on 15 new items and Rs1 billion from revision of sales tax rate from four per cent to five per cent on local sales of five zero rated sectors.
At the same time, the government has extended the GST measures initiated in March for a period of four months to the next year. It will yield an additional Rs101 billion.
Of these alone the GST on fertilizer will yield Rs35 billion, pesticides Rs2 billion, tractors Rs7 billion, plant and machinery Rs26 billion. A sum of Rs30 billion will be collected from five zero rated sector domestic sales and Rs1 billion from sugar.
But contrary to this, tax officials said that the relief measures taken under GST/FED regime would yield a net revenue loss of Rs52.4 billion.
This includes Rs35 billion revenue loss owing to downward revision of GST rate from 17pc to 16pc, Rs6 billion because of abolishing of 2.5 per cent special excise duty and Rs12 billion because of reduction in FED on cement and complete FED withdrawal on white cement. FED on cement will be withdrawn completely in two years.
Tax officials said that the net revenue impact from the tax measures taken in the budget would be negative. However, they said that FBR would raise Rs50 billion from administrative measures next year that would offset the revenue loss.
But the March taxation measures, continued to the next year, would yield a revenue of over Rs100 billion. This revenue along with the administrative measure would help the FBR to reach easily the revenue target of Rs1,952 billion for next year. This also shows the concentration on revenue collection from GST in the budget.
Contrary to these GST measures, government has proposed to raise basic income tax exemption limit to Rs350,000 from Rs300,000 per annum to give relief to lower salaried people. This will give a relief to around 80,000 taxpayers. Those with monthly salary below Rs29,629 will not pay income tax. However, they will have to file tax returns.
Against this, government has facilitated wealthy people more by increasing the limit of filing wealth tax statement to Rs1 million from existing Rs0.5 million. And it has scrapped the proposal to re-introduced wealth tax for them.
The rate of withholding tax on cash withdrawal from bank is to be reduced to 0.2 per cent from existing 0.3 per cent. All these measures are proposed to cause a loss of Rs3.8 billion income tax.
The government has imposed 16 per cent GST on 15 new items. These include computer software, surgical tapes, ultrasound gel, diapers for adults (patients), bricks, building blocks of cement including ready mix concrete blocks, ambulances, fire fighting vehicles, waste disposal trucks, breakdown lorries, special purposes vehicles for the maintenance of streetlights and overhead cables.
The GST is to be imposed on aircraft, ships of gross tonnage exceeding 15 LDTs, excluding those for recreational or pleasure purpose, spare parts and equipment for aircraft and ships, equipment and machinery for pilotage, salvage or towage for use in ports or airports, equipment and machinery for air navigation, equipment and machinery used for services provided for handling of ships or aircraft in a customs port or airport and import and supply of fully dedicated CNG Euro-2 buses whether in CBU or CKD condition.
The GST rate has been enhanced to three per cent from two per cent on commercial importers at import stage to yield additional revenue of Rs3 billion, eight per cent FED on sugar imposed replacing GST, rationalised FED on filter rod of cigarettes from Re1 per rod to 20pc ad val and FED enhanced to Rs10 per kg from existing Rs5 per kg on un-manufactured tobacco.
However, government has withdrawn FED on 15 items ranges in the range of five to 16 per cent. These include solvent oil (non-composite), other fuel oils, mineral greases, transformer oil, other mineral oil excluding sewing machine oil, waste oil, carbon black oil (carbon black feedstock) including residue carbon oil, methyl tertiary butyl ether (MBTE), greases, viscose-staple fibre.
Moreover, government has reduced FED on aerated beverages from 12 per cent to six per cent, withdrawn FED on services provided by property developers or promoters, exempted local supply of reclaimed lead to recognised manufacturers of lead batteries and allowed full adjustment of sales tax paid on import or local purchase of capital goods.
The government has withdrawn regulatory duty on 397 luxury items, excluding five items, leading to a revenue loss of Rs2.2 billion. The five items that will be subject to the regulatory duty are betel nuts, luxury vehicles of 1,800cc and above, arms and ammunition, cigarettes and luxury tyres and bathroom sets.
It has reduced customs duty by five per cent on raw material used in pharmaceutical products, cut duty to zero per cent from five and 15pc on import of 15 components used in CNG compressors, reduced duty to five per cent from 20 per cent on sabutol used in butyl acetate industry, slashed duty to 10pc from 20pc on mirror backing paint and from 10pc to 5pc on waste-scrap of glass.
Customs duty concession has been announced for oil exploration companies, raw materials of audio cassettes, and incentive for hi-tech car audio manufacturing, tariff rationalisation on bars, rods and profiles of refined cooper and copper alloy.
A fee collection has been proposed for goods imported under the Afghan transit trade agreement.
Under the income tax, the government has also proposed to withdraw capping of Rs0.5 million from voluntary pension fund and tax holiday for five years for 100pc equity investments to be effective from July 1, 2011.
To encourage investment in shares, the maximum cumulative limit for investment has been fixed at 10pc instead of 15pc of the taxable income with upper limit for investment at Rs0.5 million.
To encourage listing of companies on stock exchange, the existing tax credit has been enhanced to 10pc from five pc and the rate of tax on asset management companies’ dividends raised to 20pc from 10pc.
To encourage non-residents’ investment in securities the withholding tax of 10 per cent is proposed to be a final taxation. The government has also withdrawn 0.01pc CVT on modaraba certificates and instruments of redeemable capital traded at stock exchange.

Raise in salary of govt workers proposed


Finance Minister Hafeez Shaikh delivering budget speech in National Assembly.—APP
ISLAMABAD: The federal finance minister has proposed an increase of 15 per cent in the salary of government employees, including personnel of the armed forces.
In his budget speech on Friday, Finance Minister Dr Abdul Hafeez Shaikh said the government employees who retired on or after July 1, 2007, would get a raise of 15 per cent in pension and those who retired on or before June 30, 2002, would be allowed an increase of 20 per cent.
He pointed out that last year the government allowed an ad-hoc monthly allowance equal to 50 per cent of the employees’ basic pay. An increase was also made in the medical allowance and pension.
The minister said that despite severe financial constraints the government fully realised that its employees and pensioners were facing enormous difficulties in making ends meet. In order to provide some relief to them, measures were being proposed that were likely to take effect from July 1.
Mr Shaikh said that conveyance allowance was proposed to be enhanced by 25 per cent for all employees in BPS-1 to BPS-15. All the civil servants and armed forces personnel would be allowed enhanced conveyance allowance regardless of their place of duty.
He also announced ‘compulsory monetisation’ of transport facility for the federal government civil servants in BPS-20 to BPS-22.

Rs56bn to be spent on internal security


The allocation is Rs1.5 billion more than the Rs54.58 billion spent this year. – File Photo
ISLAMABAD: The government will spend Rs56 billion on internal security of the country during 2011-12 as the intensity of terrorist attacks, especially after the killing of Al Qaeda chief Osama bin Laden in Abbottabad, has made the job of the departments concerned more challenging.
The projected allocation includes Rs5.8 billion for various projects under the Public Sector Development Programme (PSDP).
It is not known how much money will be spent on training police and civil armed forces personnel and what steps are being taken to equip them with latest weapons and other apparatus.
Most of the money allocated for security departments will be spent on pay and allowances, accommodation and construction of buildings.
The allocation is Rs1.5 billion more than the Rs54.58 billion spent this year.
The break-up of the allocation shows that Rs457.13 million has been earmarked for the interior division, Rs4.77 billion for Islamabad police and local administration, Rs856.57 million for passport outfit and Rs24.08 billion for civil armed forces.
The Frontier Constabulary will get Rs5.63 billion, Coast Guards Rs1.71 billion and Rangers Rs11.45 billion, while Rs1.96
billion has been set aside for ‘other’ expenditures.
A sum of Rs755 million has been allocated for the administration of public order, Rs14 million for prison administration, Rs85 million fire protection and operation and Rs1.05 billion for police.
Significant projects to be financed under the PSDP include the Integrated Border Management System (IBMS) for which Rs220.58 million has been allocated.
During the year, Rs102 million will be spent on raising the Balochistan Constabulary, Rs25 million on conversion of B- into A- areas in Balochistan and Rs300 million on setting up the National Forensic Science Agency headquarters and the Islamabad laboratory.
The Pakistan Automated Fingerprint Identification System (PAFIS) Phase-II has been allocated Rs300 million, procurement and installation of a Non-Intrusive Vehicle X-Ray System (NVIS) Rs150 million, Machine-Readable Passport and Visa Project’s phase-I Rs60 million and Phase-II Rs900 million, construction of accommodation for Bhitai Rangers in Karachi Rs200 million and for Abdullah Shah Ghazi Rangers Rs200 million.
A sum of Rs81.17 million has been allocated for hardware and software upgrading of the National Data Warehouse at Nadra headquarters, Rs497 million for the Islamabad development package, Rs30 million for the construction of a Judicial and Administration Complex in Islamabad, Rs147 million for the Population Welfare Programme and services in Islamabad, Rs300 million for the National Response Centre for Cyber Crimes Phase-II, Rs39.91 million for allied facilities at the National Public Safety commission building.
Purchase of land and allied facilities under occupation Qalat Scouts in Balochistan will cost Rs120 million and Rs186 million has been earmarked for the Safe City Islamabad Project.

A huge disconnect


Prime Minister Syed Yusuf Raza Gilani and Federal Minister for Finance Dr. Abdul Hafeez Sheikh coming towards the Parliament for presenting budget 2011-12.-APP
Compared to his budget speech last year, the finance minister’s speech yesterday was empty and disappointing. It was devoid of much content or merit and failed to identify or address any of Pakistan’s numerous pressing problems.
It is difficult to say what more he would have added had he not faced much of the abuse hurled at the government, something which only a full reading of the text will reveal.
Based on what he presented just a day earlier in the form of Pakistan’s Economic Survey for the current financial year, the budget presented by the finance minister yesterday for the fiscal year 2011-12, confirms what many economists have been saying for some time.
There is a huge disconnect between the real problems which afflict Pakistan’s economy and its people, and the government’s response to them. It seems that this government does not have the ability, or perhaps even the desire, to address Pakistan’s key economic problems.
It certainly does not have a plan. What makes matters for worse is that this is the last-but-one budget before elections are held and the budget to be announced next June will have to be a populist election budget which tries to win votes rather than take difficult decisions.
Because of this, the budget presented yesterday was a major disappointment and fails to address Pakistan’s economic problems, and will only make matters worse.
The key problems which were identified in the Economic Survey included persistent and high inflation, persistent and low growth, low revenue collection leading to a high fiscal deficit which continues to add to the overall debt, and a dramatic fall in the investment rate. These are the core issues which affect Pakistan’s economy, and required a major and forthright attack, nothing short of this.
However, the government’s efforts have failed to deal with any of these issues. Blaming floods, the continuing war on terror, or the rise in global petrol prices or the global economic slowdown, does not allow for any excuses.
If anything, these significant constraints on the economy should have provided the impetus for major departures from the past.
The core problem facing Pakistan, which has a bearing on development, on debt and on defence expenditure, as well as on aid and donor dependence, is that of taxation and revenues. Without raising taxes, none of Pakistan’s economic problems can be resolved.
The finance minister in his speech admitted that only 1.5 million people have filed their tax returns this year, only half of those who are registered. By stating that 70,000 people have been given notices with 700,000 more expected, does not constitute a tax policy.
Moreover, by raising the taxable income level to Rs350,000 and saying that this will give relief to ‘lakhs’, i.e., they will no longer be in the tax net, is also at odds with what is required.
The ‘azm’ which he said his government has to expand the tax net, stands contradicted by announcements in the budget. This will also certainly not help achieve the overly optimistic budget deficit target of 4 per cent.
The ‘relief’ announced in the budget was mainly for government employees who will benefit through some measures related to their permissible benefits and, especially, due to the 15 per cent pay rise which builds on the 50 per cent increase in the last budget which, however, came in for particular criticism by most economists.
There have also been some other measures which offer some sectoral relief, such as to the cement sector affecting construction, and some lowering duties on soft drinks.
Since he was not able to read through the full text, one hopes that the measures he skipped were more substantive than these.
The announced development expenditure for 2011-12 has been increased from the announced Rs468 billion last year to Rs730 billion yesterday, or less than 4 per cent of GDP.
The truth behind these figures is that this year development expenditure, which has been cut throughout the year, will probably be one-third of what was announced, or about 1.5 per cent of GDP. One should expect the same the next year, and the rising trends in unemployment and poverty are unlikely to be reversed on account of government initiatives.
One should add in passing that Bangladesh which announced its budget a few days ago has allocated 7 per cent to development, and their economy is doing far better than Pakistan’s.
Moreover, with military and security-related expenditures nearing around Rs800 billion and debt servicing the same amount, we are back to the bad old days of the past, when there was very little left over for development.
The inflation rate of 14 per cent this year is unlikely to fall on account of the one per cent fall in the GST rate, especially since international food prices are expected to rise over the next year and oil prices continue to remain unstable, both important causes of domestic inflation.
The expectations that many of us had from the finance minister, that he would announce far-reaching and bold reforms which affect revenue generation, the deficit, military expenditure, as well as inflation, have not been met.
The huge disconnect which this government has demonstrated in terms of issues of security, ‘sovereignty’, the dominance of the civilian government over the military establishment, over foreign policy, and even in relation to the judiciary, have all been reconfirmed and re-emphasised with regard to economic issues as well.

The economic picture


Even many African economies have out-performed us in recent years, according to the Economic Survey for 2010-11 released on Thursday. - Illustration by Dawn.com
THE outgoing fiscal was yet another year of uphill economic struggle for the vast majority of Pakistanis due to decelerating growth and rising prices. Investment dried up, unemployment escalated and poverty increased.
Ranked as the third-fastest expanding Asian economy after China and India in the middle of the last decade, Pakistan is now among the slowest growing South Asian countries. India, Sri Lanka and Bangladesh are forging ahead. Pakistan`s economy is expected to expand by 2.4 per cent this year as the region is projected to grow by 8.7 per cent and the world`s developing nations by 6.5 per cent. Even many African economies have out-performed us in recent years, according to the Economic Survey for 2010-11 released on Thursday. This officially sums up the economic dilemma Pakistan has been facing for the last three years.
The Survey blames the country`s poor economic performance on a number of persisting factors. Deteriorating security conditions, flood losses, rising global oil prices, stalled external capital flows and delays in fiscal and tax reforms are the main culprits that have slowed growth and strained the government`s resources, leading to a huge build-up in domestic and foreign public debt for financing the budget. Investment has contracted to 13.4 per cent of the size of the economy from 22.5 per cent in 2007. Domestic savings are down to 9.5 per cent from 16.3 per cent in 2006. Growing energy shortages and a higher cost of borrowing continue to haunt private investors and affect industrial output. Public-sector enterprises continue to eat into meagre resources at the cost of public services like education; development expenditure formed only 3.4 per cent of GDP.
Still, there are some positives. Exports have increased on the back of higher commodity prices. An additional income of Rs342bn has been transferred to the rural economy during one year alone, compared to Rs329bn during 2001-08. The exchange rate remains stable and inflation is down to 13 per cent from 25 per cent in October 2008. The current account is also in surplus. The government has taken several tough and politically unpopular decisions like reducing untargeted food and energy subsidies. Though it has dithered on implementing many crucial fiscal and economic reforms under pressure from its allies and the opposition, it has pledged to move ahead with its plans to eliminate subsidies, bring the powerful into the tax net, prudently manage its debt, revamp public-sector companies and limit its inflationary borrowings. Recovery remains fragile, but it can give space to launch the country on the path of growth. If the reform agenda is implemented honestly and boldly, we can move faster in our race with other South Asian economies.

Thursday, 2 June 2011

US military cuts in Pakistan 'significant'

Adm Mike Mullen, Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff - 21 May 2011 Adm Mullen said it would be dangerous to abandon Islamabad
The top US military officer has acknowledged "very significant" cuts to US military numbers in Pakistan, saying US-Pakistan ties need time to heal.
Adm Mike Mullen, head of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, said some of the US troops, mostly trainers, would remain.
Pakistan asked the US to reduce its troop presence after US special forces killed Osama Bin Laden last month.
The raid sparked deep anger in Pakistan, further damaging already strained ties with the US.
The US has provided Pakistan with billions of dollars of aid in recent years, much of it military assistance.
Washington sees its relations with Pakistan as vital in the fight against al-Qaeda and against Taliban militants in Afghanistan who use safe havens in Pakistan's tribal regions on the border.
But with al-Qaeda leader Bin Laden now known to have been living undetected almost next door to a major Pakistani military academy, many in the US Congress have questioned the value of the US aid.
'Introspection'
Before Bin Laden was killed on 2 May in a raid on his compound in northern Pakistan, the US had about 200 troops in Pakistan. Most of them were helping to train the Pakistani army.
"There clearly is an ongoing contraction of that support... and it is tied to the difficult time we are going through," Adm Mullen told reporters in Washington after a visit to Pakistan.
Anti-US protest in Abbottabad, Pakistan - 6 May 2011 There have been protests across Pakistan over the US raid to kill Osama Bin Laden
Adm Mullen said the raid to kill Bin Laden had triggered "a great deal of introspection" in Pakistan.
"They're going to have to finish that before we get back to a point where we are doing any kind of significant training with them," he said.
For now, he said, that meant "a very significant cutback in trainers".
"I think we need to give them a little time and space to do that [introspection]," he said. "And that makes all the sense in the world to me."
But he said it would be dangerous to abandon Islamabad.
"I think the worst thing we could do would be cut them off," he said. If that happened, he said, "10 years from now, 20 years from now, we go back and it's much more intense and it's much more dangerous".
Adm Mullen steps down as chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff later this year.

China rejects Gmail spying claims

Google's logo Google said the cyber-spying campaign targeted Gmail accounts of US officials and journalists
China has rejected allegations of involvement in a cyber-spying campaign targeting the Google e-mail accounts of top US officials, military personnel and journalists.
A foreign ministry spokesman said it was "unacceptable" to blame China.
Google has not blamed the Chinese government directly, but says the hacking campaign originated in Jinan.
The US company said its security was not breached but indicated individuals' passwords were obtained through fraud.
Google said Chinese political activists and officials in other Asian countries were also targeted from the Shandong city, which is 400 km (250 miles) south of Beijing.
The White House said it was investigating the reports but did not believe official US government e-mail accounts had been breached.
Safety tips
It is extremely difficult for analysts to determine whether governments or individuals are responsible for such attacks, says the BBC's Adam Brookes in Washington.
But the fact that the victims were people with access to sensitive - even secret - information raises the possibility that this was cyber-espionage rather than cyber-crime, adds our correspondent.
However, Chinese foreign ministry spokesman Hong Lei told a news briefing: "Blaming these misdeeds on China is unacceptable.
"Hacking is an international problem and China is also a victim. The claims of so-called support for hacking are completely unfounded and have ulterior motives."
On Wednesday, Google said it had "detected and has disrupted" a campaign to take users' passwords and monitor their emails.
"We have notified victims and secured their accounts," said the company. "In addition, we have notified relevant government authorities."
The e-mail scam uses a practice known as "spear phishing" in which specific e-mail users are tricked into divulging their login credentials to a web page that resembles Google's Gmail web service (or which appears related to the target's work) but is in fact run by hackers.
Having obtained the user's e-mail login and password, the hackers then tell Gmail's service to forward incoming e-mail to another account set up by the hacker.
In an advisory message released on Wednesday, Google recommends several steps for users to take to improve the security of Google products:
  1. Enable two-step verification, such as using a mobile phone to which Google sends a second password to enter on sign-in
  2. Use a strong password (mix of letters and numbers, avoiding family names, birth dates etc) for Google that you do not use elsewhere. Here's a video to help.
  3. Enter your password only into a proper sign-in prompt on a https://www.google.com domain.
  4. Check your Gmail settings for suspicious forwarding addresses or delegated accounts

Analysis

Security experts say they are seeing an increase in these so-called spear phishing incidents in which attackers go after specific information or assets and aim at "high value individuals".
One consultant described it as an "epidemic", while another said such attacks are all too easy to perpetrate given the amount of information that lives on the internet about people - from their Twitter stream to their Facebook pages to sites that trace your family tree.
A smart attacker can assemble enough information to "influence and convince" a target that they are receiving a genuine email from someone they know.

Facebook rejects NY man's claim of half-ownership

Mark Zuckerberg Mr Zuckerberg started Facebook in 2004
Facebook founder Mark Zuckerberg has said that an alleged contract and e-mails that a New York man claims entitle him to a 50% stake in the social networking site are "forgeries".
Paul Ceglia says that Mr Zuckerberg signed a contract in 2003 which gave Mr Ceglia half-ownership of Facebook.
In a court filing, Facebook and Mr Zuckerberg demand that Mr Ceglia turn over the alleged contract and e-mails.
Lawyers representing Mr Ceglia disputed Facebook's claims.
"Those so-called expert opinions have been provided without examining the actual contract which is at issue in the case," said Dennis C. Vacco, who is one of Mr Ceglia's attorneys.
'Cut-and-paste job'
In a filing made at the US District Court in Buffalo, Mr Zuckerberg said he provided web development services in 2003 for StreetFax, a business Mr Ceglia was trying to start at the time.
He said he signed a contract drafted by Mr Ceglia, a wood pellet salesman, which referred only to the work he did for StreetFax.
"Zuckerberg and Ceglia never discussed Facebook and they never signed a contract concerning Facebook," the filing said.
"The contract is a cut-and-paste job, the e-mails are complete fabrications, and this entire lawsuit is a fraud."
Facebook and Mr Zuckerberg hope to use forensic testing to show that the documents are fakes.
Facebook is privately-owned but estimates of its worth range between $50bn (£30bn) and $76.4bn (£46.7bn).
Twins Cameron and Tyler Winklevoss also claimed that Mr Zuckerberg stole their website idea while they were all students at Harvard.
In 2008 they reached a settlement which gave them $20m in cash and $45m of stock valued at $36 a share.
They have since unsuccessfully tried to reopen their case against Facebook, claiming that the company concealed information and they should have received more shares.